Our History Of War Shows How Rigid Ideologies Defeat Us

“ The people of India resolved to constitute India into a Democratic, Republic and to secure to all its citizens ‘Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and opportunity’, and to promote ‘Fraternity, assuring the dignity of the individual’. […] The right to freedom of speech and expression, the right to form associations and unions, the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. […] Everyone is entitled to his thoughts and views. There are no barriers….

“ The people of India resolved to constitute India into a Democratic, Republic and to secure to all its citizens ‘Liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship; Equality of status and opportunity’, and to promote ‘Fraternity, assuring the dignity of the individual’. […] The right to freedom of speech and expression, the right to form associations and unions, the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. […] Everyone is entitled to his thoughts and views. There are no barriers. Our Constitution guarantees that.”


The following are parts of the historic judgement delivered by the Supreme Court (SC) in the case of the “State of Madhya Pradesh vs Ramashankar Raghuvanshi” on February 21, 1983. The judgement was delivered by Justice Fazal Ali, who was believed to be a ‘card-carrying communist’. The recipient, a municipal school teacher, Ramashankar Raghuvanshi, had been dismissed by the Madhya Pradesh government in 1974 for having ‘taken part in RSS activities’ – after which he had appealed to the SC.


My awakening from the classes at ISDM concerns the actions based on our ‘isms’ (which indicate the body of principles, practices and ideologies we believe in), in comparision to those based on values we are all born with as human beings (the universal values). I have understood why I shouldn’t take a stand based on my ideology or ‘isms’ – and instead base it on my values. In a way, instead of focussing on ‘what’ to achieve, I need to put my attention on ‘how’ to achieve.


In our day-to-day lives, we all carry certain biases based on our ideologies – and our tendency is to simply go with that initial reasoning and start judging the ‘others’ or the ‘opposites’. In a way, this tendency makes us blind and stops us from listening to and understanding others. The stronger our conservative beliefs, the firmer our convictions – and this is precarious.


We start thinking that the ‘others’ or the ‘opposites’ get what they deserve. We all remember the shocking images of the drowned Syrian boy and those showing the tragic plight of the refugees, or the tragic news of the Rohingya refugees of Myanmar, or news of the assassination of senior journalist Gauri Lankesh – all of which spread on social media. Often, these convictions lead to large-scale devastation. In the late 19th and 20th centuries, we have seen devastation on mammoth scales, based on the maddening fights between ideologies to prove which one is a panacea! One ‘ism’ trying to prove its supremacy over others has often lead to holocausts, mass annihilation, world wars and religious, political, ethnic and cultural fanaticism.


India, on the other hand, through her pillars of democracy and modernity, spoke of a different world view which supported peace and human values. In 1893, at Chicago, Swami Vivekananda proclaimed the message of universal tolerance and internationalism. In “The Story of My Experiments with Truth“, Gandhi pointed out that his path is based on two ideals – ahimsa (non-violence) and satyagraha (search for truth). He also stated that truth is not rigid, fixed or static – it is ever changing. Another pillar of modern India, Rabindranath Tagore, developed the concept of “Viswa Bharati”, which considers the whole universe as a teacher. None of them claimed any ‘ism’. Rather, they spoke of values like oneness, agency, dignity, freedom, equity and fraternity for oneself and others.


Based on my reflections and learning in the past few weeks, I feel that the way forward for us as humanity has to be based on kindness, healing and making peace. I find affirmation in His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s message and words which convey the same thoughts for the world. This can only be achieved by embodying the values of the inner being and their appropriate manifestation in the outside world.


Embodying the values is synonymous to feeling the greatness within oneself. Acceptance of the self is the foremost step towards being more accepting and spreading oneness in the world. We can then accept the same greatness within each human being and recognise that there is no difference between people. We are all made up of the same consciousness and our needs and values are completely similar. Until we do this, we won’t be able to empathise with the ‘other’ and connect with the ‘opposite’.


Empathy is the key to the new world order. Through value-based learning, we can connect deeply to the needs and feelings of the other, empathise and have a dialogue. The future of the earth is critically clinging to this ability for dialogue and making way for peace and harmony, instead of separating and fighting.

Author(s) :

Koushik Hore

Yes

Get in touch with authors

No ratings yet

Rate this article

Yes

Key topics

Youth Development and Leadership

Also found in

Share

Join Our Newsletter

Explore More Articles

Book

Development Management in Practice

This book is a compilation of research papers and case studies presented at ISDM’s Dialogues on Development Management (DoDM) event held in 2024. The book brings together a rich collection of empirical insights and analyses from practitioners, researchers, and development professionals engaged in strengthening the social sector in India. The volume illuminates how theory and practice intersect across three thematic pillars, Talent Management for Inclusive Development, Empowering the Marginalised through Intervention Management, and Organisational Efficiency in Sociological and Technological Dimensions, to advance the field of development management.
Paper / Report

Funders’ Perspectives on Data Maturity of Social Purpose Organisations in India

Funders’ Perspectives on Data Maturity of Social Purpose Organisations in India is an addendum to the State of the Sector Report published by ISDM CDSSI. It explores how funders view data-driven decision-making in India’s social sector. The insights in this report come from a roundtable discussion, that was held with 19 representatives, from CSRs, family foundations, philanthropic investors, outcome-based funders, and thought leaders. It shows that data maturity is a sector-wide challenge that requires collaboration, trust, and alignment between funders, SPOs, governments, and communities.
Case Study

Rooted in Trust, Rising Together

In one of Chennai’s oldest urban settlements, over 3,000 families navigate daily challenges marked by poverty, addiction, and instability. Many children return from school to difficult home environments with limited support. Amidst this, one young woman chose to respond— not with sympathy, but with sustained action. Although Vedika was overjoyed, she was left overwhelmed by the amount of work she was putting in. Fundraising, curriculum, operations, team building, trauma counselling—she was doing everything alone. There was no advisory board. No formal governance structure. Just urgency, heart, and a mounting emotional toll on her.
Event Report

Pune and Mumbai Summary Report: Systems Convening for Philanthropy for Inclusive Development

This report summarises insights from two systems thinking convenings held in Pune and Mumbai in April 2024. Organised by CPID at ISDM, the convenings engaged stakeholders to reflect on challenges and systemic traps in Indian philanthropy, and proposed collaborative, inclusive approaches for sustainable development.
We use essential and analytics cookies to operate this website and understand how visitors interact with it. As this site also functions as a login identity provider (IDP) for other ISDM portals, some cookies are necessary to enable secure authentication. By continuing to use this site, you consent to our use of cookies.